Production on the popular reality series ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ has been put on hold following a domestic incident involving star Taylor Frankie Paul and her ex-partner, Dakota Mortensen. The situation, which reportedly occurred in late February 2026, has led to an ongoing investigation by the Draper City Police Department, causing a significant pause in filming for the upcoming Season 5.
The Incident and Investigation Unfold
Details surrounding the exact nature of the dispute between Paul and Mortensen remain somewhat private due to the active investigation. However, a spokesperson for the Draper City Police Department confirmed that an official “domestic assault investigation” is underway. Crucially, the spokesperson also stated that “allegations have been made in both directions,” indicating that both Paul and Mortensen have reportedly made claims against each other. Contact was made with the involved parties on February 24th and 25th, suggesting the incident unfolded over those dates. While the police department has declined to release further specifics to protect the integrity of the investigation, the situation has understandably cast a shadow over the production of ‘Mormon Wives’.
As of the latest reports, neither Taylor Frankie Paul nor Dakota Mortensen have issued public statements regarding the allegations. The lack of direct comment from those involved only adds to the speculation and concern surrounding the incident. The series, known for its candid portrayal of the lives of women within the Mormon community, has always navigated sensitive personal topics. However, this particular event has brought the show’s production to a standstill, highlighting the serious nature of the allegations being investigated.
Background: Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen’s Relationship
Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen share a child, a daughter named Ever, who was 23 months old at the time the reports surfaced in March 2026. Their relationship has been a significant part of the narrative in ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,’ with viewers having followed their journey, including their previous breakup. The couple’s split was previously attributed to Mortensen’s infidelity.
In Season 2 of the show, Paul openly discussed the circumstances of their separation. She revealed that shortly after the birth of their daughter, Ever, she and Mortensen were living together and experiencing a period of happiness. Paul had even been contemplating engagement. However, this idyllic phase was shattered when she discovered that Mortensen had been unfaithful throughout their relationship. Mortensen himself acknowledged his dishonesty, admitting that he had lied “selfishly to protect myself.” He expressed deep regret for his actions, stating, “I just wish I was honest with her but it’s too late.” He further conveyed his desire to reconcile, saying, “I would do anything to have my family, to be with Taylor.” His admission of hurting her badly and facing the consequences of his actions was a pivotal moment in the series.
The history of trust issues and infidelity in their past relationship makes the current domestic assault investigation particularly sensitive. It raises questions about the dynamics between the former couple and the impact of their past on their present interactions, especially concerning their co-parenting of Ever.
Impact on ‘Mormon Wives’ Season 5
The immediate and most visible consequence of the domestic dispute is the halt in production for ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ Season 5. The show, which relies on capturing the real-life experiences of its cast members, cannot proceed while such serious allegations are under investigation. The decision to pause filming is a standard procedure in such circumstances, prioritizing the well-being of those involved and ensuring that any production activities do not interfere with legal proceedings.
The uncertainty surrounding the investigation means that there is no clear timeline for when filming might resume. This could have significant implications for the show’s release schedule and the overall narrative arc planned for Season 5. Fans of ‘Mormon Wives’ will likely be eager for updates, but the priority remains the resolution of the investigation and the safety and well-being of all parties concerned.
The series has often delved into the complexities of relationships, family dynamics, and personal challenges within the context of the Mormon faith. This incident, however, brings a real-world legal drama into the forefront, potentially shaping the direction of future seasons if production does eventually restart. The producers and network will undoubtedly be monitoring the investigation closely to determine the best course of action moving forward.
What We Know So Far: A Summary
- Domestic Assault Investigation: Draper City Police are investigating allegations of domestic assault between Taylor Frankie Paul and Dakota Mortensen.
- Mutual Allegations: Police have confirmed that claims have been made by both Paul and Mortensen.
- Production Halted: Filming for Season 5 of ‘The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives’ has been suspended.
- No Public Statements: Neither Paul nor Mortensen have publicly commented on the ongoing investigation.
- Past Relationship Issues: The couple previously broke up due to Mortensen’s admitted infidelity.
- Shared Child: Paul and Mortensen are parents to a young daughter, Ever.









